Skip to content 
Cedar Shake Roof Replacement Services
When your cedar shake roof has reached the end of its life, the decision you make next matters for the next 30 to 50 years. Wolf Development helps Chicagoland homeowners choose the right path — and execute it flawlessly.
Unparalleled Roofing Craftsmanship in Every Material
Unlike most roofers, we’re certified experts across a full spectrum of premier systems, from old-world slate to modern metal.
When Cedar Shake Reaches the End of Its Life
Cedar shake is one of the most beautiful roofing materials ever put on a home — and it was the default choice for luxury construction throughout the 1970s, 80s, and 90s across Chicagoland’s finest neighborhoods. But cedar is a natural material, and natural materials age. After 25 to 35 years, which is exactly where thousands of North Shore and western suburb homes sit right now, the signs of failure are hard to miss.
Curling and cupping at the shake edges. Bare patches where shakes have cracked or blown off. Moss and algae growth in shaded sections. Granule debris collecting in the gutters after rain. And sometimes, water staining on interior ceilings — the sign that the roof has already started letting weather in.
At that point, repair only buys time. The underlying material is compromised, and patching individual shakes while the rest of the roof continues to deteriorate is a delay, not a solution. Cedar shake roof replacement is the right call, and the sooner it happens, the less collateral damage occurs.
The Wolf Development Promise
When Cedar Shake Reaches the End of Its Life
Your Replacement Options: Cedar, Synthetic, or Upgrade
When a cedar shake roof reaches the end of its life, homeowners have three realistic paths forward. The right one depends on your priorities, your home, and how long you plan to stay.
The first is replacing like-for-like with new cedar shake. Premium-grade new cedar is still a legitimate and beautiful roofing choice. For homeowners committed to the natural wood aesthetic, it’s a real option — though it comes with the same ongoing maintenance requirements and a similar 25 to 30-year lifespan before the process repeats.
The second path is synthetic shake. Products like DaVinci Bellaforté Shake and Brava Cedar Shake replicate the look of natural cedar almost exactly while eliminating maintenance requirements and extending functional life to 50 years or more. For most homeowners replacing an aging cedar shake roof today, this is the most practical long-term decision. The third option is a full material upgrade to natural slate or synthetic slate — for homeowners who want to make the roofing decision once and never revisit it. We’ll walk you through all three during your consultation, with honest assessments of cost, longevity, and what makes the most sense for your specific home.
What the Replacement Process Looks Like
Cedar shake roof replacement on a large premium home is not a one-day job, and it shouldn’t be treated as one. The right process takes time, and rushing any phase creates problems that show up later.
It starts with a full assessment — not a drive-by quote. We inspect the existing shakes, the underlayment, the deck condition, the flashing at every penetration point and valley, and the ventilation system. If there’s deck damage or deteriorated underlayment that’s been masked by the cedar for years, we find it before we start, not mid-project. Once the old material is stripped, we prep the deck, install appropriate new underlayment, and begin the new roof installation in sections. For most large Chicagoland homes, the full replacement takes four to seven business days depending on roof complexity, pitch, and material. We protect your landscaping throughout and do a thorough cleanup each evening.
You’ll have a detailed written estimate before any work starts. If we discover deck damage once we’re into the project, we document it, show it to you, and price the additional scope before proceeding. No surprises — that’s a guarantee.
The Wolf Development Promise
How We Work
Since 2016
Serving Chicagoland
Trusted by Premier Roofing Manufacturers
Roofing Partners in Quality
We only install materials we’d trust on our own homes.
Featured Projects
Our Roofing Projects Speak for Themselves
Our Latest Roofing Insights
- Licensed & Insured
- GAF Master Elite
- DaVinci Certified
- Since 2016
Ready to Replace Your Cedar Shake Roof?
If your cedar shake roof is showing its age — or you’ve already had a leak and know it’s time — we’re ready to help. Schedule a free inspection and we’ll come to your home, assess the full condition of your roof, and walk you through your replacement options with no pressure and no obligation.
Your Roofing Questions, Answered
Everything you need to know about working with Wolf Development.
How do I know if my cedar shake roof needs full replacement or just repairs?
Age is the most reliable indicator. Cedar shake roofs in the Chicago area typically have a functional lifespan of 25 to 35 years. If your roof is in that range and showing multiple signs of wear — curling shakes, moss growth, missing sections, or any interior leaking — full replacement is almost always the right call. Repairs at that age address symptoms, not the underlying deterioration.
How does synthetic shake compare to natural cedar shake?
Synthetic shake products like DaVinci and Brava replicate the look of cedar very closely while offering significantly better durability, lower maintenance requirements, and longer warranties. Natural cedar requires periodic moss treatment, is more vulnerable to moisture and freeze-thaw cycles, and has a shorter lifespan. For most homeowners, synthetic shake is the more practical long-term choice — though natural cedar remains a legitimate option for those who prefer the real material.
Will replacing my cedar shake roof disrupt my daily routine?
The noise and activity during a roof replacement is noticeable but manageable. You don't need to leave your home. Most of our crews work standard daytime hours and we keep the site organized throughout the project. For most homes, the full replacement runs three to seven business days.
What happens if you find deck damage once the old cedar is removed?
We document it, show it to you, and price the additional scope before proceeding. We never move forward with unknown scope and bill you at the end.
Do you serve communities outside the North Shore for cedar shake replacement?
Yes. In addition to Winnetka and Lake Forest, we regularly work in Kenilworth, Glencoe, Hinsdale, Barrington Hills, Hoffman Estates, Glenview, Northbrook, Oak Brook, and throughout Chicagoland's northern and western suburbs.
Still have questions?
Reach out directly. We’re here to talk.
